A lot of people have questioned whether Basecamp or Slack is better. However, choosing between the two is not always the case. Depending on your use case, using both may prove to be the best solution. Below, we will see the detailed comparisons and differences between Basecamp vs Slack to help you decide the best collaboration platform for your team.
Basecamp vs Slack comes with several similar features, especially the ones regarding notifications and file sharing. However, you will not get the same functionality due to their inherent differences. Basecamp is primarily a project management platform, whereas Slack is a communication and real-time messaging platform. See also: Slack vs Teams.
Basecamp allows you to manage multiple projects in a single application. Here, you can switch easily from project to project, track updated files and projects, view comments, and get notifications. The dashboard shows individual cards for each project. If click on a project card, Basecamp will take you to another dashboard that shows messages, to-do lists, file sharing, and an activity log. A new user may find Basecamp a little confusing at first, especially when you are invited to a project that is already in progress, so you need to take some time to understand things.
On the other hand, Slack is a chat-based communication platform that can bring all your team members to a single central location to talk and collaborate. It has a time-based feed and shows the most recent messages. It supports public and private chats through the channels and direct messages. Slack allows unlimited conversations, and you can connect to multiple teams to stay in contact with different groups without switching apps.
Basecamp’s to-do boards are very handy and informative. It can show tasks, due dates, and delegated members in a single place. You can also set your personal to-do list to be displayed on your dashboard. One helpful feature is Basecamp allows users to forward emails into projects. To send an important notification to other team members, simply use @messaging on your comment.
Slack provides desktop notifications for new messages and direct messages. There are also red circles to indicate unread messages. Furthermore, you can customize the notification settings so that you only get notifications from messages containing specific words or select people. Slack has @messaging, and it can highlight your name in messages.
Basecamp vs Slack have different approaches towards file sharing. On Basecamp, you can add all files associated with a specific project to the project’s repository in Docs & Files. You can further segment the location into folders with color codes and notes. The advantage of this approach is that you can have a centralized location for all files, and you will not miss a file that has been uploaded to the platform. The disadvantage is that you can’t share private files to specific individuals; all files are public to all users that have access to the same project.
On the other hand, Slack has a very easy way to upload files. Simply drag-and-drop those files to Slack’s window. However, Slack does not have a centralized location for shared files, so important files can get lost quickly in a fast conversation. Fortunately, the powerful search bar is able to scan all text in file names and file content, and you can pin important messages to a special list. Still, you may want to download important files or move them to your cloud storage to avoid losing them.
Basecamp vs Slack have different meanings when it comes to team collaboration. Basecamp enables team collaboration by creating a central location for complex projects with many moving parts. Basecamp is a great choice if you need project management functions such as building files and documents, commenting, task delegation, and due dates. Basecamp doesn’t go as far as some more advanced tools (it can’t create custom workflows and GANTT charts), but Basecamp allows messaging in a project, between individuals, and through groups.
Meanwhile, Slack is a conversation facilitator where teams and individuals can talk and share files. As a messaging platform, Slack is really great. It is an ideal place for brainstorming. However, it is not suited for document management or a central source of truth for project development. This is not a big problem if you only need a communication platform or if you already has a separate project management platform.
Basecamp is able to run granular reports on tasks, projects, team members, and dates. You can also see run-downs on tasks that are due and things left in a project. All team members can run and see these reports, and you can have daily activity reports sent to your email inbox to follow progresses without logging in.
On the other hand, Slack can send weekly emails to team admins to give information regarding how much the team members are using the platform. In addition, there is a stats page that shows all-time overall usage. Paid subscription plans further give access to detailed usage information.
Basecamp does not have as many integrations as Slack, but you probably don’t need too many integrations in the first place since this platform already has project management and file repository functions. You can trigger automated actions on other apps by using an automation tool like Zapier.
Slack boasts itself for having “all apps in one place” due to the powerful integrations. The powerful search bar is especially impressive, as it can search for your connected apps in your messages. There are various integrations available, allowing you to create a custom productivity layer on top of the communication platform. People usually use Slack integrations for product releases, sales, bug tracking, customer services, and many other things. Of course, there are several automation tools supported through the integrations, including Zapier and IFTTT.
By using an automation tool, you can integrate Basecamp with Slack. This way, you can have a powerful project management platform with file repositories along with a responsive communication platform.
|- Focused on project management with file sharing and commenting||- Real-time chat-based communication platform|
|- Each project has a central file repository for shared files||- No central location for shared files, but has a powerful search bar|
|- Builds files, commenting, task delegation, and due dates||- An ideal place for discussions and brainstorming|
|- Granular reports on tasks, projects, team members, and dates||- General and detailed usage reports|
|- Fewer integrations, but supports some automation tools||- Many integrations for various needs including automation|
Basecamp should be your choice if you need a project management platform with central file repositories. The project/file handling capabilities are irreplaceable by Slack. On the other hand, Slack is more recommended if you need a real-time communication platform. The integrations are very powerful. If you can benefit from both platforms, you can use them simultaneously and integrate them using an automation tool like Zapier.